Stone Creek Coffee
Enhancing Value Proposition Messaging
Hypothesis
What the Data Told Us
During our CRO Insights, we identified the key value proposition section as a high-impact area for optimisation. While the brand had already implemented improvements using Shopify’s native theme features, we hypothesised that further refinement could deliver additional performance gains.
A/B Test
What We Did
Our hypothesis was that by enhancing the clarity and visual impact of the value propositions, customers would more quickly recognise the brand’s core benefits and feel more confident proceeding through the buying journey. We tested a new variant of the section against the original with a clearer layout and measured performance across conversion-related KPIs including Conversion Rate, Add to Cart Rate, and Subscription Revenue.
The Results
The results showed significant improvements across the board. Variant 1 outperformed the original with an 11.93% uplift in Revenue per Visitor, a 6.41% increase in Conversion Rate, and an 8.35% boost in Add to Cart Rate. Subscription metrics were particularly impressive, with a 48.33% increase in Subscription Orders per Visitor and a 42.91% rise in Subscription Revenue per Visitor. With statistical significance achieved, we implemented Variant 1 permanently.
-
11.93%
Increase in Revenue per Visitor -
6.41%
Increase in Conversion Rate -
42.91%
Increase in Subscription Revenue per Visitor
2025
WINNER
Standout CRO Agency of the Year
2025
WINNER
eCommerce Agency of the Year (Small)
2025
WINNER
UK eCommerce Medium Agency of the Year
2025
WINNER
CRO Agency of the Year
2022
WINNER
CRO Agency of the Year
2022
WINNER
CRO Agency of the Year
2022
WINNER
Dev Agency of the Year – Medium
See More A/B Tests
-
Collection Page (PLP)Increase Collection Page Conversion with Category Navigation Pills
Adding related-category pills to collection pages produced major gains in conversion, revenue per visitor and add-to-cart rate.
-
Product Page (PDP)Increase PDP Revenue with Popular Subscription Badges
Adding a Popular badge to subscription choices gave Azuna Fresh shoppers clearer direction and delivered the strongest commercial result.
-
Product Page (PDP)Increase Subscription Orders with Per-Ounce Price Framing
A clearer price-per-ounce message helped Jackson’s shoppers compare pack value and led to a significant increase in subscription orders.