Redesigning your Shopify store is often positioned as the fastest way to improve performance. But in reality, a full redesign is rarely the first or best solution.
At Blend, we typically recommend optimisation before redesign. Many conversion, UX and performance issues can be resolved through CRO, technical clean-up, and incremental improvements without touching the core structure of your site.
That said, there are scenarios where a redesign is justified.
This guide outlines five signs your Shopify store may genuinely need a redesign, along with clear context on when optimisation is enough and when a rebuild becomes the right move.
1. High Bounce Rate
If your website is driving traffic but users aren't sticking around, a high bounce rate is often one of the first red flags.
Bounce rate on its own does not mean you need a redesign.
What constitutes a "high" bounce rate varies by industry, traffic source and page type, but as a general guide:
- Consistently exceeding 60-70% on key landing pages can indicate an issue
- PDPs, Collection Pages and paid landing pages should typically perform lower than this when aligned to intent.
Before considering a rebuild, it's important to understand why users are leaving.
How To Assess Bounce Rate Properly
A meaningful bounce rate review should include:
- Segmenting traffic source (paid, organic, email, social)
- Comparing mobile vs desktop behaviour
- Reviewing entry pages, not just site-wide averages
- Pairing bounce rate with scroll depth, engagement time and exit data
This helps determine whether the issue is expectation mismatch, usability friction or technical performance.
What To Optimise Before Redesigning
In many cases, high bounce rate can be reduced through optimisation rather than a full redesign. Common areas to review include:
- Messaging mismatch between ads or search intent and landing pages
- Page speed issues caused by apps, scripts or unoptimised assets
- Poor hierarchy or CTA clarity, especially above the fold
- Navigation complexity, making it hard for users to orient themselves
- Onsite search limitations, particularly if users rely on search to find products
- UX friction on PDPs, Collection Pages or Cart
If bounce rate remains consistently high after CRO testing, UX improvements and performance optimisation, this can indicate deeper structural or other limitations within the theme itself.
In those cases, a redesign may be warranted to:
- Improve content hierarchy
- Simplify navigation structures
- Support clearer decision-making paths throughout the site
2. Mobile-Friendly Optimisation
Mobile traffic accounts for the majority of Shopify sessions, yet many stores are still designed desktop-first.
If your store struggles with:
- Cluttered mobile layouts
- Hard-to-tap CTAs
- Overloaded PDPs
- Poor mobile navigation
These issues can often be resolved through mobile-specific UX optimisation, not a full redesign.
However, if your theme:
- Was not built mobile-first
- Has rigid layouts that can't be adjusted cleanly through custom code
- Requires excessive workarounds for basic mobile usability
Then a redesign may be the more efficient long-term option.
Important Shopify 2.0 Note
Upgrading to Shopify 2.0 does not require a full redesign. A strong development agency can migrate your existing sections to Shopify 2.0, thereby unlocking:
- Flexible sections everywhere
- Cleaner templates
- Better performance
- Easier CRO iteration
A redesign is only necessary if the design system itself is hindering mobile UX.
3. Slow Loading
These days, customers expect most (if not all) things to be immediate. And if it takes too long, they will move on to the next thing - with the next thing being your competitor. Your Shopify store’s load speed is crucial in keeping customers around once they’ve chosen to visit your store.
But that’s not the only reason it’s an important part of your redesign. Search engines consider your store’s page speed as one of the main influences on your platform ranking. Pages loading within 3 seconds have a higher ranking than others, so there’s your optimal benchmark.
Site speed has a direct impact on:
- Conversion rate
- Bounce rate
- SEO performance
In most cases, slow loading is caused by:
- Excessive or poorly implemented apps
- Heavy scripts
- Unoptimised images and videos
- Legacy code
You can check your speed using PageSpeed Insights, as well as identify where the main drop-offs occur, such as on the home page.
These issues can often be resolved through technical optimisation and code clean-up, without redesigning the site.
One of the most effective strategies to implement is lazy loading. Without lazy loading, your store will load all images to their full size by default, making everything take longer than it should. Lazy loading will have an impact not only on your site speed but on your SEO, too.
A redesign becomes relevant when:
- The theme architecture itself is bloated or outdated
- Performance improvements are capped by theme or code limitations that custom development can't resolve
- Core pages cannot be optimised without significant rework
If you are repeatedly hitting performance ceilings despite optimisation, the problem is no longer tactical, it's structural.
4. Synced Branding
If your store has been around for a while, you may have made adjustments over the years. It’s not uncommon for tastes to change. The problem arrives when your storefront is different compared to the public outlook shown on social media when reaching your target market.
You will need to analyse the brand vision across all marketing channels and decide visually whether these are in sync. Small things like fonts, tone of voice, and colours make a huge impact on audiences and you may notice drop-offs due to this inconsistency. You want to ensure that your brand message is consistent throughout.
Brand evolution is natural, but rebranding does not automatically require a full website redesign.
In many cases, updated branding can be rolled out through:
- Component-level updates
- Typography and colour changes
- Design system refinements
- CRO-led layout adjustments
But if your current theme:
- Cannot support your updated brand positioning
- Forces compromises in layout or hierarchy
- No longer reflects the maturity of your business
Then a redesign may be necessary to align perception with reality.
5. Security
Security issues are less visible but just as critical.
If your site is old, you may be vulnerable to security risks. Coding needs to be updated to the current standards, latest security patches, and customer data must be kept safe. As a growing company, adding more sales channels will increase your vulnerability to hacks - a risk that could be detrimental to your Shopify store.
If your store:
- Runs on outdated code
- Relies on unsupported themes or apps
- Has limited flexibility to implement security best practices
A rebuild or theme replacement may be required to ensure compliance, stability and long-term scalability.
This is especially relevant for stores that process high order volumes or operate across multiple regions.
When You Don't Need a Redesign
Before committing to a rebuild, it's important to recognise when a redesign is not the right solution.
You likely don't need a redesign if:
- Your store is already on Shopify 2.0 or can be upgraded without rebuilding
- Your code is solid
- Conversion issues are isolated to specific templates or pages (PDP, Cart, Checkout)
- Performance issues stem from apps or assets
- You have not yet run structured CRO testing
- UX friction can be resolved through incremental optimisation.
In these cases, redesigning early can introduce unnecessary risk, cost and SEO disruption.
Optimisation vs Redesign: Which Is Right
| What “high bounce rate” can look like | Bounce rate varies by industry, traffic source and page type, but as a general guide:
|
| How to assess bounce rate properly | A meaningful bounce rate review should include:
|
| What to optimise before redesigning | In many cases, high bounce rate can be reduced through optimisation rather than a full redesign. Common areas to review include:
|
| When redesign may be warranted | If bounce rate remains consistently high after CRO testing, UX improvements and performance optimisation, this can indicate deeper structural or layout limitations within the theme itself. In those cases, a redesign may be warranted to:
|
| Key takeaway | High bounce rate is a signal to investigate, not an automatic trigger for redesign. |
Not Sure Which Path is Right for You?
If you're debating between optimisation and redesign, the first step shouldn't be a rebuild. It should be clarity.
A CRO Audit will identify:
- Where users are dropping off
- What is limiting conversion
- Whether your theme, or your code, is holding you back or simply needs optimisation
A Final Thought
A redesign is sometimes the right answer. But it should be a strategic decision, not a default reaction.
Most Shopify stores can unlock significant gains through optimisation first. The best outcomes come from knowing when to rebuild and when not to.
