Stone Creek Coffee
Subscription vs One-Time Prices on Collection Pages: Can Showing Both Improve Subscription Rates?
Hypothesis
Pricing Clarity is Important on PLPs
Pricing clarity on collection pages is critical to conversion performance. With a CRO audit client we found an opportunity to improve it - the discount benefit of subscription pricing was not always immediately visible while users were browsing product listings. Users were only presented with the price difference on the PDP. We hypothesised that displaying both the one-time purchase price and the subscription price directly on product cards would better show the value of subscribing earlier in the shopping journey. With the subscription discount shown at the browsing stage, users could evaluate their options sooner, potentially increasing subscription adoption, conversion rate, and overall revenue performance.
A/B/C Test
Variant 1 | Subscription Price Anchoring
Variant 1 displayed the “From” price using the subscription price, positioning the lower recurring price as the primary reference point on the product card. This variation made subscription pricing more visible during browsing and significantly increased subscription behaviour.
A/B/C Test
Variant 2 | Dual Price Display
Variant 2 displayed both the one-time purchase price and the subscription price directly on the product card, allowing customers to immediately compare the two options. This variation maintained strong subscription improvements while delivering the strongest revenue performance overall.
The Results
While Variant 1 displayed strong impacts with subscription orders per visitor increasing by 22%, subscription revenue per visitor growing by 40%, conversion rate increasing by 3%, revenue per visitor increasing by 4%, and average order value increasing by 2%, Variant 2 displayed higher changes.
For Variant 2, strong subscription improvements were maintained while delivering the strongest revenue performance overall. Conversion rate increased by 2%, revenue per visitor increased by 5%, and average order value increased by 4%. Subscription metrics also increased, with subscription orders per visitor rising by 17% and subscription revenue per visitor by 14%. This confirmed that highlighting subscription pricing earlier in the browsing experience encourages adoption without disrupting the purchase flow.
-
5%
Increase in revenue per visitor -
17%
Increase in subscription orders per visitor -
14%
Increase in subscription revenue per visitor
2025
WINNER
Standout CRO Agency of the Year
2025
WINNER
eCommerce Agency of the Year (Small)
2025
WINNER
UK eCommerce Medium Agency of the Year
2025
WINNER
CRO Agency of the Year
2022
WINNER
CRO Agency of the Year
2022
WINNER
CRO Agency of the Year
2022
WINNER
Dev Agency of the Year – Medium
See More A/B Tests
-
Product Page (PDP)Increase Subscription Orders with Clearer PDP Benefits
Rebuilding the subscription selector around clearer savings and flexibility led to a substantial lift in subscription orders.
-
Collection Page (PLP)Increase Mobile Conversion with Multi-Image Product Cards
Adding a second image to collection-page product cards improved mobile conversion, but the desktop response led to a device-specific rollout.
-
Cart & CheckoutIncrease Checkout Conversion with Rebuy Recommendations
A Rebuy recommendation widget added a new checkout cross-sell opportunity while conversion and revenue increased.